The recent controversy surrounding Hailey Welch, widely referred to as the "Hawk Tuah girl," arose when she threw the ceremonial first pitch at a New York Mets game. Welch gained notoriety for her viral social media videos showcasing her unique hawk-themed dance, which incorporates a performance style featuring exaggerated arm movements and an avian aesthetic. However, when she was invited to the game, her pitch was met with fierce backlash from Mets fans and sports commentators alike.
Critics, including sports radio host Mike Francesa, criticized Mets management for the decision to have Welch throw out the first pitch, labeling it as an "awful decision." They argued that Welch's social media persona combined with her lack of athleticism did not befit a Major League Baseball (MLB) event. Social media erupted with comments, many users expressing their discontent and questioning the appropriateness of having Welch represent the team in such a significant role. Some deemed her throw—an erratic and wayward pitch—as emblematic of her unpreparedness and a disservice to the tradition of the ceremonial first pitch, which is usually reserved for notable figures or athletes .
In response to the backlash, Welch expressed her feelings on social media, explaining that while she appreciated the opportunity, she understood the criticisms. Welch emphasized her passion for entertaining and thanked those who supported her, despite the ridicule . The incident highlights the intersections of social media fame and traditional sports culture, sparking ongoing debates about what constitutes an appropriate representation at sporting events.