5

Nesheiwat Out

6.5 43

President Trump withdrew Dr. Janette Nesheiwat’s nomination for Surgeon General, replacing her with Dr. Casey Means, a wellness influencer closely tied to Robert F. Kennedy Jr. The decision was influenced by criticisms from conservative figures regarding Nesheiwat's pro-vaccine stance.

Left-leaning sources express outrage and betrayal over cuts to 9/11 health services, condemning the Trump administration's actions as a disgraceful abandonment of heroes and victims.

Right-leaning sources express excitement and approval over Trump's nomination of Casey Means, viewing her as a refreshing, health-focused alternative, heralding a return to common-sense policies against traditional, establishment medicine.

Generated by A.I.

In May 2025, President Donald Trump announced the nomination of Dr. Casey Means as the new U.S. Surgeon General, a surprising move that followed the withdrawal of Dr. Janette Nesheiwat's nomination. Nesheiwat, a well-known figure and Fox News contributor, was reportedly replaced at the last minute due to concerns over her past statements regarding vaccines, which had drawn significant media attention and scrutiny.

Dr. Casey Means, a physician and wellness influencer, is recognized for her advocacy of a holistic approach to health, emphasizing nutrition and lifestyle changes rather than conventional medical treatments. She is closely associated with Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a prominent anti-vaccine advocate, which has raised eyebrows and concerns among public health experts. Critics argue that her nomination signals a shift away from established public health practices, particularly in the context of the ongoing vaccination debates in the U.S..

Means co-founded a health technology company and has built a following through her social media presence, where she promotes wellness and preventive care. However, her views on vaccines have sparked controversy, leading to fears that her leadership could undermine public health initiatives. Supporters of Means argue that her emphasis on lifestyle and preventive health could bring a fresh perspective to the Surgeon General's office, which has often focused on traditional medical interventions.

The nomination has ignited discussions about the future direction of U.S. public health policy, especially as the nation grapples with vaccine hesitancy and the lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. As the confirmation process unfolds, the implications of Means' appointment for public health strategy and vaccine advocacy remain a focal point of contention.

Q&A (Auto-generated by AI)

What are Dr. Casey Means' qualifications?

Dr. Casey Means earned her MD from Stanford University and is known for her focus on wellness and holistic health. She co-founded the health technology startup 'Levels' and authored 'Good Energy,' which emphasizes the importance of metabolic health. Means advocates for a shift away from traditional, pharmaceutical-heavy medicine towards more integrative approaches.

Why was Dr. Janette Nesheiwat withdrawn?

Dr. Janette Nesheiwat's nomination was withdrawn by President Trump due to significant backlash from conservative factions, particularly for her previous endorsements of COVID-19 vaccinations and mask mandates. Critics, including far-right figures, expressed concerns about her perceived alignment with pro-vaccine policies, leading to her removal as the nominee.

What is the MAHA movement in healthcare?

MAHA stands for 'Make America Healthy Again,' a movement that promotes a more holistic and wellness-oriented approach to healthcare. This philosophy often emphasizes lifestyle changes, preventive care, and alternatives to conventional medicine, aligning with the views of figures like Dr. Casey Means and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

How does Trump's choice reflect political trends?

Trump's nomination of Dr. Casey Means reflects a broader trend within certain political circles favoring alternative health perspectives over traditional medical practices. This shift indicates a growing skepticism towards established health guidelines, particularly among conservative constituents who prioritize personal choice and wellness advocacy.

What role does Robert F. Kennedy Jr. play?

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. serves as the Secretary of Health and Human Services under President Trump. He is known for his controversial views on vaccines and public health, advocating for a more holistic approach to health. His influence is evident in the nomination of Dr. Casey Means, who shares similar philosophies and has been closely associated with him.

What criticisms has Dr. Means faced?

Dr. Casey Means has faced criticism for her lack of traditional medical experience, having dropped out of a surgical residency. Detractors label her a 'wellness influencer' rather than a qualified medical professional, questioning her suitability for the role of Surgeon General, especially given her ties to controversial figures like Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

How do past surgeon general nominees compare?

Past surgeon general nominees typically have extensive backgrounds in public health, medicine, or academia. In contrast, Dr. Casey Means' nomination is notable for her lack of traditional government or public health experience. This shift towards influencers and non-traditional candidates signals a potential change in the expectations and qualifications for such high-profile health roles.

What impact do influencer doctors have today?

Influencer doctors like Dr. Casey Means can significantly shape public perceptions of health and wellness, often leveraging social media to reach wide audiences. Their emphasis on alternative health practices and personal narratives can inspire shifts in consumer behavior and public discourse, but they also risk spreading misinformation if not grounded in scientific consensus.

What are the implications of health policy changes?

Changes in health policy, especially those influenced by figures like Dr. Casey Means and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., may lead to a re-evaluation of public health strategies, particularly regarding vaccination and preventive care. Such shifts can impact funding, research priorities, and the overall direction of health initiatives, potentially polarizing public opinion.

How has public opinion shifted on vaccine policies?

Public opinion on vaccine policies has become increasingly polarized, especially in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. While many still support vaccinations as essential for public health, a growing segment, influenced by alternative health advocates, questions vaccine safety and efficacy, reflecting a broader skepticism towards governmental health recommendations.

Current Stats

Data

Virality Score 6.5
Change in Rank NEW
Thread Age 33 hours
Number of Articles 43

Political Leaning

Left 22.2%
Center 36.1%
Right 41.7%

Regional Coverage

US 88.4%
Non-US 11.6%